Little Sis just opened her first investment account, and she’s showing Big Sis the screen. “I’m investing $500 a month. And the fee is only 1%!” She says “only” like it’s a coupon.
Big Sis nods. “Same $500 a month for me. My index fund charges 0.05%.” Little Sis shrugs. “One percent, point-oh-five percent. Basically the same thing, right?”
That’s Sister vs Sister, Episode #17. Below, we run both accounts month by month for 40 years to see what investment fees really do to your money, why a “tiny” percentage turns into a six-figure gap, and exactly how to find out what you’re paying right now.
The Setup: Same Money, Same Investments, Different Fee
- Little Sis: invests $500 at the end of every month and pays a 1.00% annual fee on her balance. It could be an advisory fee, a fund’s expense ratio, or both added together. The math works the same way.
- Big Sis: invests the same $500 a month in an index fund with a 0.05% annual expense ratio.
Important: this is an illustrative example, not a prediction or investment advice. Both sisters invest for 40 years (480 deposits, $240,000 total) and earn the same assumed 7% a year on average before fees, credited monthly with no ups and downs. Each month the account grows, then one-twelfth of the annual fee comes off the balance, then the $500 goes in. We use nominal dollars (not adjusted for inflation), ignore taxes (think 401(k) or IRA), and leave out any other costs. Real returns are not guaranteed, they swing from year to year, and your results will differ.
The Race: $994,171 vs $1,294,018
We ran both accounts in Python, one month at a time. Here’s where each sister stands at a few checkpoints.
| Year | Total put in | Little Sis (1% fee) | Big Sis (0.05% fee) | Gap | Fees paid so far (1% / 0.05%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $60,000 | $81,914 | $86,303 | $4,389 | $3,677 / $190 |
| 20 | $120,000 | $230,861 | $258,879 | $28,018 | $18,603 / $1,005 |
| 25 | $150,000 | $346,186 | $401,826 | $55,640 | $32,920 / $1,822 |
| 30 | $180,000 | $501,697 | $603,967 | $102,270 | $53,981 / $3,068 |
| 40 | $240,000 | $994,171 | $1,294,018 | $299,847 | $126,551 / $7,627 |
Assumptions: $500 deposited at the end of each month for 40 years ($240,000 total); 7%/yr average return before fees (7%/12 per month), same for both; annual fee charged monthly on the balance (1.00% vs 0.05%); order each month = growth, fee, deposit. Nominal dollars, no taxes, no inflation adjustment, no other costs. Gaps are differences between the rounded balances shown. Illustrative only.
At year 10, Little Sis has a point. The gap is only $4,389, and she’d barely notice it on a statement. But the gap doesn’t grow in a straight line. It’s about $28,000 at year 20, about $56,000 at year 25, and over $100,000 at year 30. By year 40, Little Sis has $994,171 and Big Sis has $1,294,018. That’s $299,847, almost $300,000, and about 23% less money for the sister who paid the “tiny” fee.
Where Did $300,000 Go?
Little Sis only paid $126,551 in fees over 40 years. Big Sis paid $7,627. So how is the gap $299,847? Because it has two parts:
- Extra fees paid: $118,924. That’s $126,551 minus $7,627.
- Growth that money never got: $180,923. Every dollar taken as a fee in year 5 is a dollar that can’t compound for the next 35 years.
Add them up: $118,924 + $180,923 = $299,847. The lost growth is actually bigger than the fees themselves. It’s compound interest working in reverse.
Why “only 1%” is bigger than it sounds
A 1% fee isn’t 1% of your gains. It’s 1% of your whole balance, every year, whether the market is up or down. In our example the investments earn 7% a year before fees, so a 1% fee takes about one-seventh (14%) of that return. The 0.05% fee takes less than 1% of it.
And because the fee is a percentage, it grows as your account grows. In year 1, Little Sis’s fee is about $28. In year 40 alone, it’s about $9,651. Big Sis pays about $625 that year.
The SEC makes the same point. Its investor bulletin How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio says fees “may seem small, but over time they can have a major impact on your investment portfolio,” because they reduce the amount of money earning a return. Its own example: $100,000 growing 4% a year for 20 years ends at approximately $208,000 with a 0.25% annual fee, $198,000 with 0.50%, and $179,000 with 1.00%.
What about a 0.5% fee?
We ran a middle case too. With the same assumptions and a 0.50% fee, the account reaches $1,140,890 after 40 years, with $69,735 in fees paid. That’s still $153,128 behind Big Sis. Every slice of a percent counts.
Why Index Funds Tend to Cost Less
Investor.gov defines an index fund as a mutual fund, ETF, or unit investment trust that follows a passive strategy designed to get approximately the same return as a particular index before fees. It notes that passive management usually means less trading and lower fees and expenses than actively managed funds, and that “over time, higher fees and expenses can significantly lower investment returns.”
That doesn’t mean every index fund is cheap or every higher-cost option is bad. But the SEC’s page on mutual fund and ETF fees and expenses sums up the trade-off: “A fund with high costs must perform better than a low-cost fund to generate the same returns for you.”
6 Steps to Find (and Cut) Your Investment Fees
1. Look up each fund’s expense ratio
The expense ratio is the percentage of a fund’s average net assets used each year to pay its operating expenses, and you’ll find it in the fund’s prospectus fee table. List every fund you own, in your 401(k), IRA, and brokerage account, and write down its expense ratio. The SEC explains that fund operating expenses are passed on to investors as indirect fees: they’re deducted from the fund’s assets and lower your returns.
2. Find your advisory or account fee
If someone manages your money, there may be a fee on top of the fund costs. The SEC bulletin lists where to look: account opening documents, Form CRS (the client or customer relationship summary), Form ADV if you’re an advisory client, fee schedules, and your account statements and trade confirmations. You can look up a firm’s relationship summary, which covers the fees and costs you’ll pay, at Investor.gov/CRS.
3. Add up your all-in cost
Fees stack. For example, a 0.80% advisory fee on top of funds with a 0.30% expense ratio is roughly 1.1% a year, more than Little Sis pays in our example. In a workplace plan, the SEC notes that plan administration costs may be passed on to you in addition to the expenses of the funds you hold.
4. Compare with FINRA’s Fund Analyzer
The SEC suggests shopping around and points to FINRA’s free Fund Analyzer to compare the fees and other costs of certain securities, including mutual funds and ETFs. Check whether a lower-cost fund covers the same part of the market as the one you have.
5. Ask the questions out loud
From the SEC’s list: How do you get paid? What fees will I pay to buy, hold, and sell this investment? How can I reduce or eliminate some of the fees I’ll pay? How much does this investment have to increase in value before I break even? The bulletin also says that in some cases fees are negotiable, so ask.
6. Check the cost of switching before you move
Before you sell or transfer anything, the SEC says to think about tax consequences and any fees for closing or transferring your account. In a 401(k), compare the expense ratios on your plan’s fund menu and pick the lowest-cost fund that fits your plan. And keep grabbing your employer match first. It’s free money that no fee comparison beats.
FAQ
What is an expense ratio?
It’s the yearly cost of owning a fund, shown as a percentage of your investment. Per Investor.gov, it’s the percentage of a fund’s average net assets used each year to pay operating expenses, listed in the prospectus fee table.
Is a 1% fee high?
It depends on what you get for it, but it’s never “tiny” over decades. In our example, 1% instead of 0.05% left Little Sis with about $300,000 (23%) less after 40 years.
Is a financial advisor worth a 1% fee?
Sometimes. Good advice may help you stick with your plan and handle bigger decisions. Just know the price in dollars, not only as a percentage, and ask whether other ways to pay (like a flat fee) are available.
Are index funds always the cheapest option?
Not always. Investor.gov says passive management usually means lower fees than active management, but costs vary from fund to fund. Check each fund’s expense ratio.
Will I see the expense ratio on my statement?
Usually not as a separate charge you pay. The SEC describes fund operating expenses as indirect fees deducted from the fund’s assets, which lowers your return. That’s why you need to look it up in the prospectus or on the fund’s page.
The Bottom Line
Same $500 a month. Same investments. Same 7% a year before fees. After 40 years, Little Sis’s “tiny” 1% fee leaves her with $994,171, while Big Sis’s 0.05% index fund grows to $1,294,018. The gap is $299,847: $118,924 in extra fees plus $180,923 of growth that money never got. You can’t control the market, but you can control your investment fees. Spend 15 minutes this week finding your expense ratios and fees. Then let time do the rest, the way it does when you start investing early.
Watch the Short Video Version
Watch the money piles grow (and the fee jar fill up) in Sister vs Sister, Episode #17:
▶ Watch the short video version on YouTube (@sistersndollars)
This post is for educational purposes only and isn’t financial or investment advice. All figures are an illustrative example assuming $500 invested at the end of each month for 40 years, a 7% average annual return before fees (not guaranteed), and annual fees of 1.00% vs 0.05% charged monthly on the balance, in nominal dollars with no taxes, inflation, or other costs; real returns vary and your results will differ. See our Disclaimer for details, including our affiliate disclosure.
Our Paycheck Budget Planner (Google Sheets/Excel) does the math for every paycheck — $5.
Get the Paycheck Budget Planner →
Leave a Reply