Little Sis bursts in waving an offer letter. “This office job pays five grand more. Seventy-five K!” Big Sis doesn’t look up from her laptop on the balcony. “I’m staying remote at seventy. So which of us wins?” Little Sis grins. “Me, obviously.”
Then Big Sis starts doing math out loud. Taxes take about fifteen hundred. The 20-mile drive each way eats about thirty-one fifty in gas and car wear. “So I’m only up… three sixty?” says Little Sis. “For 200 hours in traffic,” says Big Sis. That’s $1.81 an hour.
That’s Sister vs Sister, Episode #23. Below we run the full office job vs remote job math: what a $5,000 raise is worth after tax, what 9,600 commute miles really cost, how the answer changes with distance and hybrid days, and how to count any raise before you say yes.
The Setup: $75K in the Office vs $70K at Home
- Little Sis (office): takes a $75,000 job with a 20-mile, ~25-minute drive each way, five days a week.
- Big Sis (remote): stays at her $70,000 remote job. Her commute is the hallway.
- Same everything else: both are single filers with no state income tax, working 240 days a year (48 weeks × 5 days). These are our assumptions.
Important: this is an illustration, not a verdict on your job. Your taxes, car, distance and benefits will be different, so we show the math step by step and then flip the assumptions.
Step 1: The $5,000 Raise After Tax
Under the IRS’s 2026 tax numbers, the standard deduction for a single filer is $16,100, and the 22% bracket covers taxable income over $50,400 (24% starts above $105,700). Taxable income is $53,900 for Big Sis and $58,900 for Little Sis, so both sit in the 22% bracket, and every dollar of the extra $5,000 is taxed at 22%. Add 7.65% for Social Security and Medicare (FICA):
| Office¹ | Remote¹ | Gap | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Salary | $75,000 | $70,000 | +$5,000 |
| Federal tax² | −$7,670 | −$6,570 | −$1,100 |
| FICA (7.65%) | −$5,737.50 | −$5,355 | −$382.50 |
| After tax | $61,592.50 | $58,075 | +$3,517.50 |
¹ Office = Little Sis, Remote = Big Sis. ² 2026 federal income tax for a single filer with the $16,100 standard deduction, no other income, no pre-tax deductions or credits, and no state income tax (all assumed). Rounded to the cent.
So the “five grand” is really $3,517.50 in her pocket. The other $1,482.50 (29.65%) goes to taxes. A state income tax would shrink it further. For a full walk-through of where a salary goes before payday, see where a $60K salary really goes.
Step 2: What 9,600 Commute Miles Really Cost
20 miles × 2 trips × 240 days = 9,600 miles a year. To price them, we used AAA’s Your Driving Costs 2025. AAA’s weighted average for new 2025 vehicles shows the total yearly cost of owning and driving a car at 15,000 and at 20,000 miles a year. The difference is what each extra mile costs:
| Miles/yr* | Total cost/yr |
|---|---|
| 15,000 | $11,577 |
| 20,000 | $13,220 |
| +5,000 | +$1,643 |
| Per extra mile | 32.86¢ |
* AAA Your Driving Costs 2025, weighted average of top-selling 2025 models. 32.86¢ = $1,643 ÷ 5,000 (rounded to 32.9¢ in the video).
That 32.86¢ is roughly 13.00¢ of fuel, 11.04¢ of maintenance, repairs and tires, and about 8.84¢ of extra depreciation (AAA adds $442 a year for the higher mileage). We left out insurance, registration and loan interest, because Little Sis pays those whether she commutes or not.
9,600 miles × 32.86¢ = $3,154.56 a year. Now the scoreboard:
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Raise | +$5,000.00 |
| Taxes (29.65%) | −$1,482.50 |
| Commute† | −$3,154.56 |
| Net gain | +$362.94 |
| Hours driving‡ | 200 |
| Per hour | $1.81 |
† 9,600 mi × 32.86¢ (AAA 2025 extra-mile cost). ‡ ~25 min each way × 2 × 240 days. No tolls, parking or lunches included.
Two hundred hours is five full 40-hour work weeks behind the wheel, unpaid, for $362.94. Is 25 minutes realistic? The Census Bureau says the average one-way trip to work was 27.2 minutes in 2024, and 69.2% of workers drove alone. Little Sis’s commute is a little shorter than average.
What If the Numbers Change?
The biggest swing is how you price a mile. Here are three common ways:
| Per mile* | Commute | Net/yr | Per hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24.03¢ gas+maint | $2,306.88 | +$1,210.62 | $6.05 |
| 32.86¢ AAA | $3,154.56 | +$362.94 | $1.81 |
| 76¢ IRS | $7,296.00 | −$3,778.50 | −$18.89 |
* 24.03¢ = AAA 2025 operating cost only (fuel + maintenance). 76¢ = IRS business standard mileage rate for July 1–Dec. 31, 2026, a business-deduction rate shown here as a high-end estimate. 9,600 miles, 200 hours.
Even counting only gas and maintenance, the raise pays about $6 an hour to commute. At the IRS rate, the office job is about $3,779 a year behind. Distance matters too:
| One way | Miles/yr | Commute | Net/yr |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 mi | 2,400 | $788.64 | +$2,728.86 |
| 10 mi | 4,800 | $1,577.28 | +$1,940.22 |
| 15 mi | 7,200 | $2,365.92 | +$1,151.58 |
| 20 mi | 9,600 | $3,154.56 | +$362.94 |
| 25 mi | 12,000 | $3,943.20 | −$425.70 |
| 30 mi | 14,400 | $4,731.84 | −$1,214.34 |
After-tax raise of $3,517.50 minus 32.86¢ per mile, 240 workdays. Illustration only.
At 32.86¢ a mile, the after-tax raise covers a commute of about 22.3 miles each way. Go farther and the higher salary leaves her behind. Counting only gas and maintenance, the break-even is about 30.5 miles.
Hybrid Days Change Everything
Many offers aren’t all-or-nothing. Same $75K, same 20-mile drive, but fewer office days:
| Office days | Commute | Net/yr | Hours | Per hour |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5/week | $3,154.56 | +$362.94 | 200 | $1.81 |
| 3/week | $1,892.74 | +$1,624.76 | 120 | $13.54 |
| 2/week | $1,261.82 | +$2,255.68 | 80 | $28.20 |
| 0 (remote) | $0 | +$3,517.50 | 0 | — |
48 weeks a year, 20 mi and ~25 min each way, 32.86¢ per mile, after-tax raise $3,517.50. Illustration only.
Two remote days a week are worth about $1,262 a year in car costs and 80 hours of her life (5 office days vs 3). That’s why a hybrid schedule is worth negotiating as hard as salary.
How to Count Any Raise Before You Say Yes
1. Shrink the raise to after-tax dollars
Multiply the raise by your top federal rate plus 7.65% FICA, plus any state tax. At 22% federal, $5,000 becomes $3,517.50. That’s the number to compare.
2. Price the commute per mile, not per tank
Round-trip miles × workdays × a per-mile cost. Use about 24¢ for gas and maintenance only, or about 33¢ to include extra wear on the car (AAA 2025). Note that the IRS says regular commuting isn’t tax-deductible, no matter how far you drive (Publication 463).
3. Add tolls, parking and lunches
These weren’t in our math, and they add up fast: every $1 per workday is $240 a year. Just $1.51 a day of parking, tolls, coffee or lunch upgrades wipes out Little Sis’s entire $362.94. Count work clothes, dry cleaning and after-work takeout, too.
4. Divide by your hours
Net gain ÷ commuting hours = what the raise pays you to commute. If that number is lower than you’d accept for a side job, the offer needs to improve.
5. Negotiate what fixes the math
Ask for remote or hybrid days, a higher salary that actually covers the drive, or a commute stipend. A taxable $100-a-month stipend would add about $844 after tax (at 29.65%), lifting Little Sis to about $1,207 a year, or $6.04 an hour. Big Sis’s one-sentence negotiation script works for these asks, too.
6. Give the money a job
If you take the office job, plan where the extra lands. If you stay remote, the gas money you don’t spend is real savings. Move it to savings or debt payoff on payday so it doesn’t vanish.
FAQ
Office job vs remote job: which pays more?
The office job pays more on paper, but not always in your pocket. In our example, a $5,000 raise left $3,517.50 after 22% federal tax and FICA, and a 20-mile commute cost $3,154.56, leaving $362.94 a year for 200 hours of driving.
How much does commuting cost per mile?
It depends on what you count. AAA’s 2025 study puts gas plus maintenance at 24.03¢ a mile (weighted average). Adding the extra depreciation from more miles brings the cost of each extra mile to about 32.86¢. The IRS business standard mileage rate (76¢ from July 1, 2026) is much higher, but it’s a deduction rate for business driving, not a measure of your extra cost.
Can I deduct my commute on my taxes?
Generally no. IRS Publication 463 says driving between your home and your main or regular place of work is a personal commuting expense, and you can’t deduct it no matter how far you live.
How long is the average commute?
The Census Bureau’s American Community Survey put the average one-way travel time to work at 27.2 minutes in 2024, up from 26.8 minutes in 2023.
The Bottom Line
Little Sis’s $75K looked like a $5,000 win. After taxes she keeps $3,517.50, the 20-mile drive costs about $3,154.56, and she’s left with $362.94 a year, or $1.81 for each hour in traffic. Big Sis wins this round. Before you take a raise with a commute, run it through tax, miles and hours.
Watch the Short Video Version
See which sister wins in Sister vs Sister, Episode #23:
▶ Watch the short video version on YouTube (@sistersndollars)
This post is for educational purposes only and isn’t financial, tax, legal or career advice. The salaries, the 20-mile and ~25-minute commute, 240 workdays, single filing status, no state income tax and no pre-tax deductions are assumptions for illustration. Car costs use AAA’s 2025 national weighted averages; your vehicle, gas prices and taxes will differ. See our Disclaimer for details, including our affiliate disclosure.
Our Paycheck Budget Planner (Google Sheets/Excel) does the math for every paycheck — $5.
Get the Paycheck Budget Planner →
Leave a Reply